A good dog food is one that is well balanced and provides optimum nutrition for your dog's needs.  While researching dog foods available commercially I was surprised to find that many of the brands I thought were quality foods did not rate as well as expected. In evaluating these foods I made up a formula based on the ingredients, nutritional information and grade of the ingredients.  More ratings, similar to mine, and the basic model for mine.  Dog food listings.  My formula is as follows:

  • Starting with 100 percent as a grade
  • I took away 10 each for animal by-products & non-human grade ingredients
  • I took away 10 for BHA, BHT or ethoxyquin
  • I took away 5 for every ingredient repeated in another form (rice flour, brewer's rice...)
  • I took away 3 if their was less than 2 meat sources
  • I took away 3 for animal digest
  • I took away 3 for corn
  • I took away 3 for animal fat within top 10
  • I took away 2 for soy
  • I took away 2 for wheat
  • I took away 1 for salt within top 10 ingredients
  • I took away 1 for color
  • I took away 1 for sugar or molasses
  • I added 5 if had been tested by AAFCO and met criteria
  • I added 5 if was endorsed by major breed or club
  • I added 3 for pro or prebiotics
  • I added 3 each for fruit or vegetables
  • I added 2 if hormone & antibiotic free, pesticide free, preservative free
  • I added 2 for barley
  • I added 2 for flax
  • I added 1 if main protein source was animal based
  • I added 1 for glucosamine & chondriotin
  • i added 1 for vitamin and minerals
resulting grade: A = 94+, B = 86-93, C = 78-85, D = 70-77, F = 69-

NATURE'S RECIPE

   Large Breed Ckn & Oatmeal - A

   Adult lamb & Rice - A

   Large Breed Puppy - A

PRO PAC

   Chunk - A

   Lamb & Rice - B

   Chicken & Rice - B

   Large Breed Adult - B

   Large Breed Puppy - B

   Puppy Lamb & Rice - B

ROYAL CANIN

   Bulldog 24 - B

BIL-JAC

   Select - C

   Puppy - C

KIBBLES N BITS

   Original - F

   Wholesome Medley - F

OL ROY

   Adult - F

   Puppy - F

Active Care  -  B

Annamaet  - B

Avoderm Natural Original  -  A

Blue Buffalo Lg Breed Chicken/rice  -  A

By Nature natural Active  - B

California natural Chicken/rice  -  B

Canidae ALS Chicken, Turkey, Lamb  -  A

Cycle Natural  -  B

Diamond Maintenance  -  B

Eagle pack Kennel  -  B

Evolve Chicken  -  A

Fromm Advanced  -  A

Merrick Cowboy Cookout  -  B

Natural Life Advanced  -  A

Premium Edge Chicken  -  B

Professional Choice  Chicken  -  A

Show Bound Natural  -  A

Star Pro Premium  -  C

Triumph Chicken Rice  -  A

RECIPES

Cheese Please Treats

  • 1 1/2 c wheat flour
  • 1 1/4 c grated cheddar
  • 1 stick butter
  • 1 T minced garlic
  • 1/4 c low fat milk
  • form balls, lay on floured cookie sheet, press flat
  • 375, 20 minutes
Peanuty Crunch Treats
  • 1 c oatmeal
  • 2 c wheat flour
  • 1 c peanut butter
  • 1 c water
  • 1/4 c peanut oil
  • 1 egg, beaten
  • roll out, cut shapes
  • 350, 20 minutes then flip and 20 minutes more
  • cool completely
Bully Beef Treats
  • 2 1/2 c wheat flour
  • 1/2 c powdered milk
  • 1 egg
  • 1/2 banana
  • 1/2 c beef broth, hot
  • 1 T brown sugar
  • mix, roll, cut shapes
  • ungreased pan
  • 300 for 30 minutes
Healthy Me Treats
  • 1 c flour
  • 1 c corn meal
  • 1/2 c wheat germ
  • 1 lb liver
  • blend in blender
  • drop balls on cookie sheet, flatten with glass coated in water and corn meal
  • 350, 20 minutes
Baby Me Treats
  • 3 jars strained meat baby food
  • 1/4 c cream of wheat
  • 1/4 c powdered milk
  • 350, 15 minutes
  • store in fridge
Better Breath Treats
  • 2 c wheat flour
  • 1/2 c corn meal
  • 1 T mint
  • 1/2 c parsley
  • 3/4 c chicken broth
  • 6 t canola oil
  • greased cookie sheet
  • roll 1/4" thick, cut shapes
  • 350, 40 minutes... cool overnight
Flea Free Treats
  • 1 1/2 c beef broth, boiling
  • 2 c wheat flour
  • 1 c corn meal
  • 2/3 c brewer's yeast
  • 2 T garlic powder
  • 2 egg yolks
  • roll 1/4" thick, cut shapes
  • 375, 20 minutes, cool overnight
Chicken Meal
  • 1 c chopped chicken breast
  • 1/2 c brown rice
  • 1/2 c vegetables
  • 4 T chicken broth
  • Boil chicken and vegetables and rice
  • Add broth
  • Cool slightly and serve
  • Refrigerate left overs


 

SCIENCE DIET

   Large breed Lamb & Rice - A

   Adult - B

   Puppy - B

EUKANUBA

   Healthy Joints - B

   Boxer - C

   Large Breed Lamb & Rice - B

   Natural Lamb & Rice - B

SPORTMIX

   Large Breed Adult - C

   Lamb & Rice - C

   Bite Size - C

   Puppy - F

IAMS

   Mini Chunks - D

   Lamb & Rice - D

   Healthy Naturals - C

   Puppy - D

PEDIGREE

   Ckn, Rice, Veg - F

   Puppy - F

   Adult - F

PURINA

   Adult - F

   Puppy - F

  • Results of a NC Dept of Agriculture and Consumer Service Study on Dog Foods 2001-2002  click here 
free templates
Make a Free Website with Yola.